When it comes to choosing the right food for your feline friend, Earthborn Cat Food stands out as a trusted name in holistic pet nutrition. Owned by Midwestern Pet Foods, a family-operated company since 1926, Earthborn Holistic focuses on high-quality, natural ingredients to support your cat’s health. With a commitment to sustainability and balanced nutrition, Earthborn Pet Food offers grain-free and whole-grain options tailored to the needs of obligate carnivores.
In this comprehensive review, we’ll dive into the brand’s history, evaluate five top-rated Earthborn Cat Food products, highlight their pros and cons, answer frequently asked questions, and provide a comparison table to help you make an informed decision.
About Earthborn Holistic: A Legacy of Quality
Earthborn Cat Food is a product line under Midwestern Pet Foods, a fourth-generation family-owned business based in Evansville, Indiana. Founded nearly a century ago, the company started as a small milling operation and evolved into a leader in premium pet food. Earthborn Pet Food emphasizes a holistic approach, using high-quality proteins, nutrient-rich fruits, vegetables, and superfoods. The brand is also eco-conscious, with initiatives like the UPCs for Trees program, which supports global reforestation, and recyclable packaging to reduce environmental impact.
The Earthborn Pet Food lineup includes wet and dry foods, with grain-free and whole-grain options to cater to various dietary needs. Their recipes are crafted without artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, ensuring your cat gets natural, wholesome nutrition. However, the brand has faced challenges, including a 2021 recall due to potential salmonella contamination in products from their Monmouth, Illinois facility. Despite this, Earthborn Pet Food maintains a strong reputation for quality and transparency.
Top 5 Earthborn Cat Food Products for 2025
Below, we review five top-rated Earthborn Cat Food products available on Amazon, focusing on their ingredients, nutritional value, and suitability for cats. Each product is evaluated based on quality, customer feedback, and alignment with feline dietary needs.
1. Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
Overview
This grain-free dry food is designed for all life stages, making it ideal for kittens, adults, and seniors. It features high-quality protein sources like turkey meal, chicken meal, and Pacific whiting meal, paired with antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables such as blueberries, cranberries, and spinach.
Key Ingredients:
- Turkey meal (primary protein source)
- Chicken meal
- Peas
- Dried egg product
- Blueberries, cranberries, carrots, and spinach
Nutritional Profile (Dry Matter Basis):
- Protein: 40%
- Fat: 15.6%
- Carbohydrates: 36.4%
Pros:
- High protein content supports obligate carnivore needs.
- Grain-free formula suits cats with grain sensitivities.
- Includes probiotics for digestive health and chelated minerals for better absorption.
- Antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables boost immunity.
- Formulated for all life stages, reducing the need to switch foods.
Cons:
- Contains pea protein, which is less biologically valuable than animal protein.
- Some cats may find the small kibble size less appealing.
- Higher carbohydrate content compared to wet foods.
Best For: Cats with grain allergies or those needing a high-protein diet.
Customer Feedback: Pet owners on Amazon praise the palatability, noting that even picky eaters enjoy it. However, some report digestive issues in sensitive cats, likely due to the pea protein or potato content.
2. Earthborn Holistic Harbor Harvest Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
Overview
This wet food features a blend of tuna, salmon, and whitefish in gravy, flaked straight from the bone for maximum flavor. It’s grain-free and rich in omega-3 fatty acids, promoting healthy skin and coat.
Key Ingredients:
- Tuna
- Salmon
- Whitefish
- Carrots and peas
- Taurine and essential vitamins
Nutritional Profile (Dry Matter Basis):
- Protein: 59.9%
- Fat: 11.4%
- Carbohydrates: 20.7%
Pros:
- High protein content aligns with a carnivore’s diet.
- Over 80% moisture aids hydration, reducing risks of kidney issues.
- Dolphin-safe fish sourcing ensures ethical production.
- No artificial preservatives or fillers.
- Highly palatable for picky eaters.
Cons:
- Contains sunflower oil, a plant-based fat less ideal for cats.
- Some cans arrived dented in Amazon shipments, raising concerns about packaging.
- Menadione sodium bisulfite (controversial vitamin K source) is included.
Best For: Cats needing hydration support or those who prefer wet food textures.
Read More: Northwest Naturals Cat Food Review
Customer Feedback: Customers on Walmart and Amazon report their cats love the taste, with improved coat health after regular use. However, some noted digestive upset in cats sensitive to fish-based diets.
3. Earthborn Holistic Chicken Catcciatori Grain-Free Canned Cat
Overview:
This wet food mimics a natural carnivore diet with shredded chicken in a broth-based recipe. It’s grain-free and includes essential vitamins and minerals for balanced nutrition.
Key Ingredients:
- Chicken broth
- Chicken
- Potatoes
- Sunflower oil
- Guar gum
Nutritional Profile (Dry Matter Basis):
- Protein: 53%
- Fat: 12%
- Carbohydrates: 9%
Pros:
- Meat-based with chicken as the primary ingredient.
- High moisture content supports urinary health.
- Free of artificial ingredients.
- Affordable compared to other premium wet foods.
- Suitable for cats with fish allergies.
Cons:
- Potatoes add unnecessary carbohydrates.
- Sunflower oil is less optimal than animal-based fats.
- Some cats experienced digestive issues, possibly due to potatoes.
Best For: Cats with fish allergies or those needing a budget-friendly wet food.
Customer Feedback: Amazon reviews highlight its appeal to picky eaters, but some owners reported vomiting in cats sensitive to potatoes.
4. Earthborn Holistic Wild Sea Catch Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
Overview:
This dry food features salmon and herring meal as primary proteins, making it a great choice for cats who thrive on fish-based diets. It’s grain-free and enriched with taurine for heart health.
Key Ingredients:
- Salmon meal
- Herring meal
- Peas
- Canola oil
- Blueberries and cranberries
Nutritional Profile (Dry Matter Basis):
- Protein: Higher than average
- Fat: Near average
- Carbohydrates: Near average
Pros:
- High-quality fish proteins support skin and coat health.
- Grain-free for cats with sensitivities.
- Includes probiotics for digestion.
- Nutrient-dense with fruits and vegetables.
- Made in the USA with trusted sourcing.
Cons:
- Canola oil is controversial and less ideal than fish oil.
- Some cats may not tolerate fish-based diets.
- Limited palatability for cats preferring poultry flavors.
Best For: Cats who enjoy fish-based foods or need omega-3 support.
Customer Feedback: Reddit users note improved coat shine, but some cats experienced diarrhea, possibly due to the richness of the fish content.
5. Earthborn Holistic Feline Vantage Whole Grain Dry Cat Food
Overview:
Unlike the grain-free options, this dry food includes wholesome grains like brown rice, oats, and barley, making it suitable for cats without grain sensitivities. It uses chicken meal as the primary protein.
Key Ingredients:
- Chicken meal
- Ground brown rice
- Pea protein
- Oatmeal
- Dried egg product
Nutritional Profile (Dry Matter Basis):
- Protein: 40%
- Fat: 15.6%
- Carbohydrates: 36.4%
Pros:
- Easily digestible grains for cats without allergies.
- High protein content from chicken meal.
- Includes taurine and omega fatty acids for overall health.
- Affordable compared to grain-free dry foods.
- Made in family-owned USA kitchens.
Cons:
- Contains pea protein, which is less ideal than meat-based protein.
- Not suitable for grain-sensitive cats.
- Lower palatability for picky eaters compared to wet foods.
Best For: Cats without grain allergies seeking a budget-friendly dry food.
Customer Feedback: Amazon reviews praise its affordability and quality, but some owners noted their cats preferred grain-free options.
Pros and Cons of Earthborn Cat Food
Pros of Earthborn Cat Food
- High-Quality Ingredients: Earthborn Pet Food uses premium proteins like chicken, turkey, and fish, with minimal artificial additives.
- Grain-Free and Whole-Grain Options: Caters to cats with or without grain sensitivities.
- Sustainability Focus: Eco-friendly initiatives like tree planting and recyclable packaging.
- High Protein Content: Aligns with the needs of obligate carnivores, especially in wet foods.
- Made in the USA: Produced in family-owned facilities with rigorous quality control.
- Hydration Support: Wet foods contain over 80% moisture, aiding urinary health.
Cons of Earthborn Cat Food
- Recall History: A 2021 recall for potential salmonella contamination raised concerns, though no illnesses were reported.
- Plant-Based Ingredients: Ingredients like pea protein, potatoes, and sunflower oil are less species-appropriate.
- Limited Dry Food Variety: Only three dry food recipes, which may limit options.
- Palatability Issues: Some cats find the food less appealing, especially dry kibble.
- Controversial Ingredients: Use of menadione sodium bisulfite in some recipes.
Comparison Table: Top 5 Earthborn Cat Food Products
| Product | Type | Primary Protein | Grain-Free | Protein (Dry Matter) | Price (Approx.) | Best For |
| Primitive Feline Dry | Dry | Turkey, Chicken | Yes | 40% | $2.50/lb | All life stages, grain allergies |
| Harbor Harvest Canned | Wet | Tuna, Salmon | Yes | 59.9% | $1.80/can | Hydration, fish lovers |
| Chicken Catcciatori Canned | Wet | Chicken | Yes | 53% | $1.50/can | Budget-friendly, fish allergies |
| Wild Sea Catch Dry | Dry | Salmon, Herring | Yes | Higher than average | $2.70/lb | Skin/coat health, fish diets |
| Feline Vantage Dry | Dry | Chicken | No | 40% | $2.20/lb | Grain-tolerant cats, budget |
*Prices are approximate based on Amazon and may vary.
FAQs About Earthborn Cat Food
Based on Google Trends and common questions about Earthborn Pet Food, here are answers to frequently asked questions:
1. Is Earthborn Holistic a good cat food brand?
Yes, Earthborn Cat Food is considered a high-quality brand due to its focus on natural ingredients, high protein content, and absence of artificial additives. It earns a B grade (43/60) from Cats.com, with strong scores for ingredient quality and species-appropriateness. However, some recipes include plant-based ingredients like pea protein, which may not suit all cats.
2. Where is Earthborn Holistic cat food made?
Earthborn Cat Food dry foods are manufactured in Midwestern Pet Foods’ facilities in the USA (Indiana, New York, Oklahoma). Wet foods are produced in Thailand by US Pet Nutrition, part of the Thai Union Group, with most ingredients sourced from the USA.
3. Has Earthborn Holistic cat food been recalled?
Yes, Earthborn Cat Food faced a voluntary recall in March 2021 for potential salmonella contamination in products from the Monmouth, Illinois facility. No illnesses were reported, and the issue was resolved.
4. Is Earthborn Holistic grain-free?
Earthborn Cat Food offers both grain-free and whole-grain options. Products like Primitive Feline and Harbor Harvest are grain-free, while Feline Vantage includes grains like brown rice and oats.
5. How does Earthborn Holistic compare to other premium brands?
Compared to brands like Wellness and Blue Buffalo, Earthborn Cat Food offers competitive pricing and similar high-protein, natural ingredient profiles. However, its limited dry food variety and occasional use of plant-based fillers may make it less appealing than brands like Orijen, which prioritize animal-based proteins.
Earthborn Cat Food vs. Competitors
Earthborn Cat Food holds its own against premium brands like Wellness, Blue Buffalo, and Orijen. Here’s a quick comparison:
- Wellness: Offers a broader range of recipes but is pricier. Both brands use high-quality proteins, but Wellness has fewer plant-based fillers.
- Blue Buffalo: Similar pricing and ingredient quality, but Blue Buffalo has a stronger focus on life-stage-specific formulas.
- Orijen: Higher protein content and fewer fillers, but significantly more expensive than Earthborn Pet Food.
Earthborn Cat Food is a great middle-ground option for pet owners seeking quality nutrition at a reasonable price, especially for cats with specific dietary needs like grain allergies.
Final Thoughts
Earthborn Cat Food offers a compelling blend of quality, affordability, and eco-conscious practices. With high-protein recipes, grain-free and whole-grain options, and a focus on natural ingredients, it’s a solid choice for most cats. The Primitive Feline and Harbor Harvest stand out for their nutritional profiles, while Chicken Catcciatori is a budget-friendly wet food option. However, the 2021 recall and inclusion of plant-based ingredients like pea protein and potatoes may concern some owners.
For cats with specific needs, such as grain sensitivities or hydration requirements, Earthborn Cat Food provides tailored solutions. Always consult your veterinarian to ensure the chosen formula meets your cat’s unique needs. If you’re ready to try Earthborn Cat Food, check out the products on Amazon for convenient purchasing and customer reviews to guide your decision.
Sources:
- Cats.com
- Cat Food Advisor
- Catster
- Only Natural Pet
- Amazon Customer Reviews: Earthborn Holistic Products
- Earthborn Holistic Official Website
Disclaimer: This blog post contains affiliate links, and as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you if you purchase products through the links provided. All opinions and recommendations in this review are my own and product descriptions, customer feedback, and analysis of available information. Always check the latest reviews and product details before purchasing. Prices and product availability are subject to change, so please verify details on Amazon before purchasing. Always consult your veterinarian before making dietary changes for your cat. Thank you for supporting this blog!
