As a devoted cat owner and Amazon affiliate, I’ve spent countless hours researching premium pet nutrition to ensure our furry companions get the best. First Mate cat food stands out in the crowded market for its commitment to high-quality, simple ingredients sourced responsibly. First Mate cat food offers versatile options like grain-free and grain-friendly varieties.
In this comprehensive review, we’ll explore five standout First Mate cat food products available on Amazon. I’ll break down their ingredients, benefits, pros, and cons based on real user feedback and expert analyses. First Mate cat food is known for using free-run chicken, wild-caught fish, and antioxidant-rich blueberries, avoiding fillers like corn, wheat, soy, and peas in many recipes.
This makes First Mate cat food ideal for sensitive stomachs and all life stages. We’ll also include a comparison table, FAQs drawn from popular search trends, and sources for transparency. Let’s dive in!
About the FirstMate Brand
FirstMate is a family-owned Canadian pet food company with a legacy rooted in sustainable practices and premium nutrition. Established in 1989 by Michael Florian, whose family operated a sustainable fishing business on British Columbia’s North Shore, FirstMate began as a way to utilize high-quality fish byproducts for pet food.
This origin story shapes FirstMate cat food’s commitment to ethically sourced ingredients, particularly wild-caught fish like herring, anchovies, and sardines, alongside cage-free chicken. Operating from a single, family-run facility in Chilliwack, Canada, FirstMate maintains strict quality control, ensuring no recalls in over 30 years—a rare feat in the pet food industry.
The brand’s philosophy centers on simple, wholesome recipes tailored to cats’ carnivorous needs. FirstMate cat food emphasizes high animal-based protein (up to 92% in some formulas) and avoids common fillers like corn, wheat, soy, and peas in many products. Their grain-free and grain-friendly lines cater to diverse dietary needs, incorporating antioxidant-rich blueberries for urinary and immune health.
FirstMate’s limited-ingredient approach makes it a go-to for cats with allergies or sensitivities, while their sustainability focus—using non-GMO ingredients and eco-conscious sourcing—appeals to environmentally aware pet owners. With a reputation for quality and transparency, FirstMate cat food continues to earn trust among pet parents seeking premium, reliable nutrition.
Detailed Review of First Mate Cat Food Products
1. FirstMate Grain Free Limited Ingredient Dry Cat Food
This flagship First Mate cat food is a grain-free, limited-ingredient dry formula featuring cage-free chicken as the single protein source. The recipe includes chicken meal (a concentrated protein), potatoes for digestibility, and whole blueberries for antioxidants. With 36% crude protein and 16% fat, it’s formulated for all life stages, making it a versatile choice in the First Mate cat food lineup. Blueberries provide urinary tract support and immune boosts, while the absence of peas, flax, and fish reduces allergy risks.
Pros:
- High animal-sourced protein (92% from chicken) promotes muscle health and energy.
- Limited ingredients make it excellent for cats with food sensitivities or allergies to grains, soy, or corn.
- Users report softer coats, reduced vomiting, and improved digestion—ideal for picky eaters.
- Affordable premium option at around $3.50 per pound on Amazon.
- No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, aligning with First Mate cat food’s clean ethos.
Cons:
- Some cats find the kibble too hard or triangular shape challenging to chew, especially seniors.
- Higher carb content (24% as-fed) from potatoes may not suit very low-carb diets.
- Occasional reports of digestive upset during transition, though a gradual switch helps.
- Not ideal for fish-allergic cats if cross-contamination is a concern, despite no fish ingredients.
Overall, this First Mate cat food earns high marks for simplicity and efficacy. One reviewer noted their allergic cat’s fur regrew nicely after switching.
2. Firstmate Pet Foods Renaissance Grain Free Cat Food With Blueberries
This fish-based First Mate cat food uses wild-caught herring, anchovies, and sardines as primary proteins, blended with potatoes and blueberries. It’s grain-free with 42% protein, emphasizing omega-3s for skin and coat health. As part of the Renaissance line, it’s hypoallergenic and supports urinary tract function through low magnesium and antioxidant berries.
Pros:
- Rich in omega fatty acids from whole fish, promoting shiny coats and joint health.
- Limited ingredients reduce allergens; great for cats sensitive to chicken or grains.
- High protein (42%) and low ash (6%) benefit active cats and kittens.
- Users praise softer fur and reduced shedding; ferals even tolerate it well after initial adjustment.
- Sustainable sourcing aligns with First Mate cat food’s ethical standards.
Cons:
- Strong fishy smell may deter some owners or picky cats.
- Higher price point (around $4 per pound) compared to grain-inclusive options.
- Some cats experience soft stools initially due to rich fats.
- Not suitable for fish-allergic pets, though it’s a single-protein focus.
This First Mate cat food is a top pick for coastal-inspired nutrition. Reviewers highlight its role in healing IBD in cats.
3. FirstMate Grain Free Chicken Meal with Blueberries Formula for Cats Dinner
A smaller bag version of the chicken-based First Mate cat food, this grain-free formula mirrors the limited-ingredient approach with cage-free chicken, potatoes, and blueberries. At 36% protein, it’s digestible and antioxidant-packed, ideal for sensitivities and daily feeding.
Pros:
- Single-protein source minimizes allergies; 92% protein from chicken.
- Blueberries aid urinary health and immunity, a unique First Mate cat food benefit.
- Smaller size perfect for trial; cats show increased energy and playfulness.
- No peas or flax, reducing common irritants.
- Affordable entry point into First Mate cat food at under $20.
Cons:
- Kibble size may be too large for kittens or small breeds.
- Potential for initial digestive adjustment, like loose stools.
- Limited availability in some regions; stock up on Amazon.
- Carb level (24%) higher than ultra-low-carb alternatives.
Perfect for testing First Mate cat food waters. Users report it resolved chronic inflammation.
4. FirstMate Grain Friendly Cat & Kitten Formula
Shifting to grain-inclusive, this First Mate cat food uses chicken and wild-caught fish with oatmeal and brown rice. With 32% protein, it’s balanced for growing kittens and adults, free of corn, wheat, soy, potatoes, and peas. Berries add antioxidants for overall wellness.
Pros:
- Grain-friendly for cats needing fiber; supports steady energy without spikes.
- Multi-protein (chicken + fish) appeals to picky eaters; maintains healthy weight.
- Affordable and versatile for all ages; users note firm stools and shiny coats.
- No GMO ingredients; ethically sourced.
- Great for multi-cat households with varying needs.
Cons:
- Lower protein (32%) than grain-free options; may not suit high-energy cats.
- Some kittens prefer wet food over this dry formula.
- Potential allergy trigger if sensitive to grains, though minimal.
- Bag size small for large households.
This First Mate cat food is praised for Bengal cats with sensitive tummies.
5. FirstMate™ Grain Friendly Indoor Cat Formula Cat Food
Tailored for indoor lifestyles, this low-fat (12% crude fat) First Mate cat food features chicken and fish with grains like oatmeal. It’s calorie-reduced for weight control, with berries for urinary support. 35% protein keeps it nutritious.
Pros:
- Low-calorie for sedentary cats; helps prevent obesity.
- Antioxidants from berries promote immune and urinary health.
- Users report softer coats, no digestive issues, and picky cats loving it.
- Free of common allergens; great for seniors or indoor-only pets.
- Ethical sourcing boosts First Mate cat food’s appeal.
Cons:
- Lower fat may not energize active cats.
- Some find it less palatable than fish-heavy formulas.
- Grain inclusion could upset grain-sensitive cats.
- Smaller bag; frequent repurchases needed.
Ideal for urinary issues; one user avoided vet food costs.
Comparison Table about First Mate cat food
| Product | Type | Key Ingredients | Protein/Fat/Carbs (DM Basis) | Best For | Price (Approx. on Amazon) |
| 1. Grain Free Limited Ingredient (Chicken, 10lb) | Grain-Free Dry | Chicken Meal, Potatoes, Blueberries | 40%/18%/42% | Sensitivities, All Ages | $35 |
| 2. Renaissance Grain Free (Fish, 10lb) | Grain-Free Dry | Fish Meal, Potatoes, Blueberries | 46%/20%/34% | Skin/Coat, Hypoallergenic | $40 |
| 3. Grain Free Chicken with Blueberries (4lb) | Grain-Free Dry | Chicken Meal, Potatoes, Blueberries | 40%/18%/42% | Trial, Digestion | $18 |
| 4. Grain Friendly Cat & Kitten (5lb) | Grain-Inclusive Dry | Chicken, Fish Meal, Oatmeal, Berries | 36%/21%/43% | Kittens, Daily Feeding | $20 |
| 5. Grain Friendly Indoor (5lb) | Grain-Inclusive Dry | Chicken, Fish Meal, Oatmeal, Berries | 39%/13%/48% | Weight Control, Indoors | $22 |
This table highlights how First Mate cat food varies by needs—grain-free for low-carb, grain-friendly for balance.
FAQs About First Mate Cat Food
Based on Google Trends and common searches, here are top questions:
Is First Mate cat food good for kittens?
Yes, formulas like the Grain Friendly Cat & Kitten support growth with high protein and no fillers.
Does First Mate cat food help with allergies?
Absolutely; limited-ingredient options reduce reactions to common allergens like grains or peas.
What are the benefits of blueberries in First Mate cat food?
They provide antioxidants for urinary health, immunity, and digestion.
Is First Mate cat food grain-free?
Many are, but grain-friendly lines include wholesome grains for fiber.
Where is First Mate cat food made?
In Canada, with controlled manufacturing for quality.
Has First Mate cat food been recalled?
No recalls in 30+ years, a strong safety record.
Conclusion
First Mate cat food delivers premium, ethical nutrition without compromising on taste or health benefits. From grain-free limited-ingredient picks to grain-friendly formulas, there’s something for every cat. As an Amazon affiliate, I recommend trying these—your cat will thank you with purrs and vitality. Always consult a vet for dietary changes.
Sources
Disclaimer: This blog post contains affiliate links, and as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you if you purchase products through the links provided. All opinions and recommendations in this review are my own and product descriptions, customer feedback, and analysis of available information. Always check the latest reviews and product details before purchasing. Prices and product availability are subject to change, so please verify details on Amazon before purchasing. Always consult your veterinarian before making dietary changes for your cat. Thank you for supporting this blog!
